I knew I could buy no more than exactly what was on her
list. She knew how much everything should cost. I needed to answer for every
penny I spent. Everything needed to add up.
This simple accountability seems to be completely missing at
our Department of transportation (DOT).
My mother has now gone to live with the angels. However, she
would be appalled at the findings in a recent audit released by the nonpartisan
Legislative Audit Bureau (LAB).
Auditors looked at spending on highways and found actual spending
on individual projects much greater than the cost estimates provided to the
Legislature at enumeration, which means legislative approval of the project. In
some cases, actual costs for highways were four times more than the approved
estimates.
Auditors examined highway projects completed from January
2006 to December 2015. At enumeration, cost estimates for none of the 19
completed projects took into account the increases in inflation during the life
of the project. In every completed major highway project reviewed, actual costs
were more than the cost estimates provided at enumeration. Over half of the
projects had actual costs that were more than DOUBLE the cost estimates at
enumeration. Two projects – including I-94 to Chippewa Falls were more than
FOUR TIMES the cost estimates provided at enumeration.
The I-94 to Chippewa Falls project was enumerated in 1991
and the last bills were paid in 2011. Why did this information not become part
of a public discussion before now?
Part of the answer lies in a lack of transparency and
oversight.
This audit, just as prior audits, illuminated problems with
missing paperwork and poor oversight. Because of prior audit findings,
legislators changed the law to require DOT to report clear information on
actual compared to budgeted costs.
Despite the new law, DOT did not provide complete
information to the oversight body - the Transportation Projects Commission,
which is made up of political appointees. The law required regular reporting by
DOT to the Commission.
Auditors also examined current DOT highway projects and
found similar problems. In every project reviewed, cost estimates in August
2016 were higher than the cost estimates at enumeration. Of the sixteen major
ongoing highway projects, eight are more than double the cost estimates at
enumeration, with one – Highway 10 from Marshfield to Appleton – over four
times greater.
Why have project cost estimates increased so much?
Auditors mention two reasons: unexpected costs and
inflation. DOT did not sufficiently consider the effects of inflation. They
also made major errors (my words, not the auditors) in their cost estimates due
to unexpected cost increases.
An example may help explain these unexpected cost increases.
In planning construction on I-39/90 from Madison to the
Stateline, DOT used five-year-old traffic counts. They updated the project with
new counts in 2012. DOT then decided to increase pavement thickness and add two
more additional lanes near Janesville. DOT bought additional real estate, moved
power lines they had not anticipated, increased the shoulder width and provided
alternate routes to avoid delays and accidents. These changes explained about
three-quarters of the nearly half a billion of the increase in the project’s
cost estimate.
All of these changes may appear reasonable. However, serious
problems exist in the system when cost estimates increase from about $700
million to over $1.2 billion with no public accountability or legislative
authority.
Auditors recommend legislators and the public are kept
better informed. In its report, the LAB makes 45 separate recommendations. In
response to the audit, Speaker Robin Vos called on DOT to provide details
related to all DOT projects and actual cost.
But how is it the Department of Transportation has paid more
–sometimes four times more – on projects than cost estimates provided at
enumeration?