Showing posts with label Social Work. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Social Work. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

National Social Worker Month


March is National Social Worker Month.

Governor Doyle commemorated this with his own proclamation:

Governor Jim Doyle today proclaimed March as Professional Social Worker Month in recognition of the hard work and dedication of Wisconsin’s professional social workers. Throughout the month, the Department of Children and Families (DCF) will recognize the incredible contributions of these caring professionals and will highlight their impact on Wisconsin children, families, and communities.

"Social workers provide important services to Wisconsin families, helping to address critical issues such as child abuse, poverty, drug dependence and mental illness," Governor Doyle said. "By raising the awareness of the important role social workers play in the success of our communities, I hope more people will consider this crucial profession.”

Social Worker Month provides an opportunity to highlight the essential role social work professionals play in alleviating some of communities’ most difficult problems. Through education, training and dedication, social workers provide assistance in many different areas of practice including health, aging, mental health, child welfare, cancer, end of life, adolescent health, HIV/AIDS and family violence.
Scott Walker commemorated the celebration by planning on laying off at least 100 of them.

Friday, April 10, 2009

Liberal Agenda Saves Money

Having worked in the mental health/social work field for a couple of decades, I know all too well that one of the favorite targets at tax cutting time is social programs. The vitriol coming from the right wing about these programs is overwhelming at times.

They would rather cut every single social program in the interest of "saving tax payer money" so that they can keep the tax cuts for the rich to become richer. But they never once look at the cost of their spending cuts.

A fine example of this is a story that recently appeared in the Seattle Post-Intelligencer. The story is about a type of group home, or halfway house, that opened in Seattle. The program was called the 1811 program, and it was subjected to a lot of controversy, open skepticism and years of protests. The reason for the controversy was that it provided housing and services, but did not demand total sobriety from the residents.

The result of this program, when is was finally allowed to launch, was remarkable (emphasis mine):
Porter's progress is echoed in a study published Tuesday in the Journal of the American Medical Association. The study, led by a University of Washington researcher, found that the once-controversial 1811 program -- which provides housing and services without demanding sobriety -- saved taxpayers more than $4 million in one year.

[...]

Researchers followed 95 chronically homeless alcoholics, who, before moving into the home, had run up a taxpayer bill of $8.2 million in hospitalizations, emergency services, jail time and sobering center visits.

After one year of being in the program, the same group cost taxpayers only $4 million, the study found. Each resident also drank less the longer they lived in the home, and their toll on publicly funded programs decreased as time went on.

[...]

Larimer also compared residents against a control group of 39 homeless alcoholics on a wait-list to get into the home. She found that the residents, after six months of being in the home, cost taxpayers 50 percent less than the wait-listed group.
I can understand why some people would be against the idea of using tax payer dollars to house alcoholics and drug addicts, especially if they are not required to be clean. But the simple fact of the matter is that these people would continue to use whether the housing was provided or not, and that would cost the taxpayers a lot more than this program does.

The same principal applies to the mentally ill. If you take away some of these people's most basic concerns and stressors, like exposure to inclement weather or extreme hunger, they are able to focus on other parts of their lives, reducing their need to use alcohol and drugs, and hopefully become productive citizens again.

Unfortunately, it makes for a sexier and easier to understand soundbite for a politician to act tough on these souls, than to do the right thing.

Tuesday, April 7, 2009

Madman McAdams

John McAdams, is a professor at Marquette University, teaching political science, or so I've been told. I wonder about the quality of his knowledge, since political science has to take into account sociology and human nature, as well as things like the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence, which he apparently knows very little about.

He takes a story from the Ann Arbor News, which tells about a young woman fired from the counseling program for not doing her job, and twists it into a tale of persecution and martyrdom.

The gist of the story, which McAdams all but plagiarizes by reprinting nearly the whole thing, is about a young woman who was assigned a case of a young man troubled by things going on in his relationship with his significant other. The problem for the young lady is that he is gay, and she believes, due to her religious convictions, that homosexuality is wrong and she refused to treat him.

McAdams, and the American Defense Fund, feel that this is religious persecution.

McAdams interprets the events thus:
Of course, a liberal social worker would never be required to condone behaviors she believed to be (say) racist or sexist. We can’t imagine that a feminist social worker would be required to counsel a Muslim woman in a way that condoned fundamentalist Islamic views about relations between the sexes. And we can’t imagine that any social worker would be required to condone sexually molesting children.

But a different standard applies to Christians.

[...]

Allowing a counselor with moral objections to homosexuality to simply hand off a client to a secular liberal colleague would seem to be a reasonable accommodation to sincere religious beliefs.

But the gay lobby (and its politically correct academic acolytes) are not about tolerance. They are about orthodoxy. Everybody must think the way they want them to think — or at least be forced to pretend that they think that way — or they will be punished.
All of this, to any social worker or mental health professional, is pretty damn offensive.

What this supposedly learned man fails to recognize is that a key part of being a good counselor or therapist is being nonjudgmental. One has to put aside their personal beliefs while on duty, in order to provide the most effective and therapeutic service they can to the person in need.

This is common among many lines of works. A police officer might have feelings of hatred towards another race, but they are not supposed to let those personal feelings interfere with the way they enforce the law.

The same could be said about doctors and nurses. What if the young lady was studying to be a doctor, and a homosexual man came in with HIV. Would he condone her withholding treatment because he was gay? Of course not. Counseling is really no different. Instead of dealing with an illness of the body, she is supposed to be dealing with stress of the emotional and/or mental sort, regardless of who the patient is.

McAdams' attitude is also probably hypocritical. I have no doubt in my mind that if the young lady was attending a religious school, and refused to follow a school rule about telling the young man that he was an abomination, he would defend the school's right to have that rule, no matter how offensive it might be.

If the young lady is unable to put aside her own prejudices, whether based on a religious or personal point of view, she has no business being in that business.

Furthermore, what if the young man was in a severe emotional state and felt like hurting himself? Her rejection of him would only exasperate the problem, and might push him over the edge. Would he condone that, I wonder.

In my years in the mental health field, I have had to work with people that I would rather not have, whether they be child molesters, child abusers, drug dealers or close-minded, neurotic professors, but I did put my feelings aside for that brief time, in order to put my best effort in making my corner of the world a better place.

Too bad McAdams can't say the same.

Friday, February 13, 2009

Three OWI Convictions In One Month

I received the weekly issue of the Waupaca County Post, and this story caught my eye (sorry, no link):
Waupaca County Circuit Court Judge John Hoffmann placed Ryan C.A. Johnson, 23, Waupaca, on three years' probation on Monday, Feb. 9.

Johnson was convicted of his fourth and fifth drunken driving offenses. He will serve 100 days in jail and pay $1,723 in fines and court costs for his fourth offense and serve eight months in jail and pay $1,748 for his fifth offense.

Johnson was convicted of his third drunken driving offense and misdemeanor bail jumping on Jan. 8 in Shawano County, where he will spend a total of 115 days in jail and pay $2,166.
This guy is only 23 years old, but has been already convicted five times for drunk driving. It has cost him thousands of dollars already, and now will cost him a good chunk of his life. However, he should be grateful he still has a life and hasn't killed himself or someone else.

I know that there has been a lot of talk about drunk driving over the past several months, with the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel doing a story on it every day for over two months and even has a blog to just cover all of the OWI stories throughout the state.

The different approaches to this problem is as diverse as the number of stories about drunk driving. There are some that advocate a complete crackdown on drunk driving, including making first offenses a criminal matter, establishing police checkpoints, lowering the blood alcohol level for drunk driving, and increasing the sentencing for drunk drivers, especially repeat offenders.

As for criminalizing the first offense of drunk driving, it seems to me that the current set up is rather counter intuitive. If driving while intoxicated is illegal the second, third, or any other number of times, why isn't it criminal the first time? Perhaps it is due to the valid concern that the offender might have made a mistake that is out of their character, and don't want to punish the person excessively. While that makes some sense, it would seem to me that we trust our judges to make their rulings based on the law, but with common sense. If we can't trust the judge's to judge if the person's background and history, then they are not very good judges.

The check point idea is a very bad one. Simply put, it is too much like a police state and it infringes on the rights of too many people, even if it might save some lives, to justify following that plan. Besides, some cops wouldn't know a drunk driver if they saw one.

I don't think lowering the BAC levels, increasing the penalties or raising the drinking age will have any meaningful impact on the issue, especially when it comes to repeat drunk drivers. Look at the young man at the beginning of this post. He had already picked up two previous offenses. I am sure that there was some penalties, like fines and the suspension of his license, but that did not deter him from going out and doing it some more.

I realize that it is emotionally and politically easier to just beat up on the drunk driver, but being a social worker and having more than a passing familiarity with psychology, I adhere to the theory that alcoholism is a disease, and needs to be treated as such. Drunk driving can be a symptom of this disease. They are generally in denial of their illness until something forces them to recognize their problem. This is common among many people who have a mental illness.

People that are arrested for their first drunk driving offense are usually ordered to have an assessment and go through a remedial driving course, but rarely is the offender offered any actual therapy or counseling to help them realize that they have a problem, on how it is hurting themselves and their loved ones. They are never given the chance to help themselves out of their downward spiral.

Instead of dumping all of this money in locking up first offenders, I would like to see some of that money be used in offering the offender a chance to get better first. Sure, the incarcerated drunk driver will have sobriety forced on them while in prison (unless they know how to make jailhouse hooch), but this won't address the underlying issue of his or her alcoholism, nor will it give them the tools to deal with it when they are released from prison.

If the person refuses to heed the advice of the counselors and therapists, and doesn't take measures to follow steps to help themselves from putting further people at risk, then they need to be taken from behind the wheel and off of the streets before someone gets hurt or killed. But while incarcerated, it is imperative that they are given the tools they will need to remain sober on the outside. Otherwise, they are only being set up for failure when they are eventually released.

Wouldn't it make sense to spend less money, keep people a productive member of society instead off a financial burden housed in a jail, and bound to continue the cycle until they die or kill someone else?

Monday, February 2, 2009

The Paranoid Professor

John McAdams is a professor at Marquette University. What he is supposed to be teaching, I don't know. I am not sure that I really want to know either.

But what he does excel at is paranoia. He sees anti-Christian bogeymen around every corner, sure that they are trying to tear down a religion that has survived for two millennia.

He is also very good at playing the martyr. He will tell you how evil you are for being gay, liberal, interested in social justice, etc., and then feign hurt when you confront him on his bigotry.

Case in point is a piece he wrote on Christmas Day. He takes a long way to try to argue that Social Workers are the Devil's workers, or something like that. Here is a piece, with the emphasis put in by yours truly:
One can, in other words, add social work to education as professions whose gatekeepers (university programs providing necessary credentials) impose an ideological litmus test.

Social work schools have particularly expressed concern that conservative Christian students might have biases that would prevent them properly serving homosexual clients.

Of course this could happen. But it could also happen that homosexual social workers or atheist social workers might let their biases prevent them from properly serving conservative Christian clients.

And students who are professed feminists certainly raise questions as to whether they can be fair to men in things like child support or child custody issues.

So what we have here is not any real, legitimate concern with professionalism, but rather raw political bias.
Now, I have to admit that I took some umbrage at his throwing around insults, when it is obvious that he doesn't even understand the subject matter that he is upset about.

First of all, for his first assertion to be correct, he would have to show me where there is a collected, organized effort by gays or atheists to deny even Constitutional rights to Christians. I don't mean the crackpots that come out every year and file their frivolous lawsuits at Christmas time, either.

However, we have seen around the country, most recently in California with Prop 8, where Christians organized and spent millions of dollars to legitimize their bigotry and homophobia.

In psychobabble, this is what is called projection. He is taking the thing he least likes about himself and puts that aspersion onto those that he doesn't approve of. And as I pointed out a long time ago, what he really is doing is just trying to mask his fear of that which is different and that he cannot understand.

The second highlighted point really displays his paranoia. It also makes me cringe to think that he may be teaching anything with the law or governmental science, since anyone with a neuron left in their head knows that it is a judge, not a social worker, that determines child support and/or child custody.

For another example of McAdam's loss of contact with reality, check out the McAdams Sutra.

Friday, November 14, 2008

Hell Is For Children (At Least In Milwaukee)

I know, I know, I'm supposed to be out of here, but when the story of the little boy that died came on the news, my wife knew I wouldn't find peace until I got this out of my system. No wonder I love that woman.

For those that aren't aware, there is a continuing story of the tragic death of a little baby boy, Christopher L. Thomas, Jr. who was murdered by his own aunt. To make the matter even worse, his two year old sister was tortured for months at the hands of their aunt as well. Indeed, Pat Benatar had it nailed in her song, "Hell Is For Children."

As if the death of the baby and the abuse of the little girl wasn't enough to anger anyone, there is much, much more that outrages me about this story.

As I've mentioned before, in 1996, the Wisconsin State Legislature wrote a line in the budget that the State would take over the child welfare system in any county with a population of over 500,000. There was only one county that fit this description - Milwaukee. That is how the Bureau of Milwaukee Child Welfare was created.

The reason for the takeover stemmed from a federal lawsuit against the state and the county in which it was purported that the rights of Milwaukee County children were being violated because they were languishing in foster care for too long. The state, the county, and the plaintiffs each had their own independent audit done. All three audits came up with the same findings. Namely, that the state was underfunding the county, which prevented the county from meeting federal guidelines and thereby violating the rights of the children.

The state disagreed with the findings of all three audits and claimed that the county was just mismanaging the funds they were being given. The state took over the system in 1998, and allowed Milwaukee County to apply for and subcontract for a greater part of the system. Within three years, the State pushed the County out of the business of taking care of their own children, and gave it to a group of various different private agencies. Many of these agencies have failed miserably, due to precious services dollars going towards all the different administrations. Meanwhile, the children continued to suffer and suffer.

And despite what conservatives might tell you about how privatization, or to be more accurate, profiteering is supposed to save tax payers money, the BMCW started out costing about $40 million more a year than when the county ran it solo. And that was before the state legislature had to pass a special law that the private agencies workers all be given raises to match those of the public sector workers. The reason for that law was because the turnover rate of private agency worker were as high as 67 %, and this was crippling the system. Now, taxpayers are on the hook for half again as much as if the state just funded Milwaukee County the way they should have in the first place.

Even with all that, complaints and issues about BMCW continued to rise to higher and higher levels.

Enough history, back to the case at hand.

Little Christopher and his sister, according to MJS were removed from their parents care about a year ago. The mother was mentally ill and the father was incarcerated. In that year, both children have been bounced from home to home (another thing that BMCW said that they wouldn't do). The boy was eventually placed in a pre-adoptive home, but then was placed with his sister in the home of his aunt and uncle.

Peter DiGuadio, poster boy for the conservative lunatic fringe, really got me angry when he wrote this piece of irresponsible, over the top, racist and ignorant rhetoric:
The little girl had been in the care of a veteran foster parent in Germantown. The two children are black. The birth parents are black; the foster parents in whose home the children suffered are black. The foster parents in West Allis and Germantown are white. Do you see a pattern here?
Race, you see, trumps everything. Child welfare Nazis willing to take children out of loving, supportive foster homes and placed into the homes of blood relatives simply because the foster parents are white and the blood relatives are black, never mind the quality of the environment of the homes of those blood relatives. We’ve seen this type of story over and over again. Looking through the eyes of political correctness, those two children didn’t belong in the loving, caring, nurturing foster homes because the foster parents were white and the children were black. There’s a mentality in the child welfare bureaucracy based out of political correctness that black children must only be raised by black parents.
If that isn’t racist, then I am not sure what would qualify. This from the same people, many of whom push for homosexual couples being allowed to be foster parents and to adopt.
Race probably had very little, if anything, to do with it. When I worked in the system, I had white children adopted by black families and more commonly, black children adopted by white families. What it most likely had to deal with was that they were family.

When the State created the BMCW, they weren't done. They then went on to create Kinship Care. Kinship Care was sold has a way to keep children with family members. All it really was was another way for the State to save money. Kinship Care would put the same abused and/or neglected children with aunts, uncles, grandparents, cousins, or adult siblings instead of foster care, but only pay the relatives half as much as they would a foster parent. Same needs, same issues, but only half the money.

Kinship Care also saved money in other ways. To have a child adopted, a home would have to be identified, gone through a very thorough and intrusive investigation and study. Then if the home passed muster, the courts would have to go through the lengthy and usually costly procedure of terminating parental rights and then months later the adoption process. After the adoption was completed, the foster parents would receive the higher level of payments of foster care, which was usually subsidized to an even higher level for special needs and to account for other issues. These payments would last until the child was the age of majority.

With Kinship Care, the relative would only receive the much smaller payments. The investigation was minimal and barely adequate in most cases. They also wouldn't end up adopting the children, but only being given guardianship, which could be reversed at any time.

In other words, these kids were removed from their potential permanent placements and put in the home where they would suffer for months and one would eventually be murdered, just to save some money.

Another problem with privatization profiteering of the child welfare system is that it pushed out all the seasoned workers and relied on poorly trained and inexperienced workers fresh out of school. That could explain how the worker, who is supposed to have had monthly visits failed to notice the signs of abuse. They had to be fairly apparent, give the severity of the abuse and the length of time.

But then again, to save money, these inexperienced workers are given heavy caseloads and the expectations put on them are not physically realistic. There are only so many hours in a day, and the amount of work required (including replicative paperwork) times the number of cases often exceeds the time that a person could put into the job.

Compounding the tragedy is the total lack of responsibility and accountability. I'm sure the worker will be fired for whatever reason they concoct, whether it be a justified one or not. But that's where it will stop. The director of BMCW, Denise Revels Robinson, will, as she does every time something like this happens, will say, "We will look into it and make all the corrections needed." But the systematic flaws will remain.

To sum this all up, due to the people in power at the time (Tommy Thompson, Alberta Darling, Margaret Farrow, Scott Walker, and a cast of dozens) it was deemed better to save a couple of bucks by bilking just another social program (always a popular move among Republicans) than have to be responsible members of the community, even if it meant raising taxes a little. Now, ten years later, we still have children being abused and murdered, a child welfare system that is all but broken, and a general sense of apathy in the community, mostly because they don't really know what is going on in their own communities. It's much easier to listen to squawkers like Sykes and Belling rant and rave about imaginary problems like voter fraud or commies/terrorists/bogiemen hiding behing every tree.

And to make the story even sadder, the only person who can claim the body of little Christopher is his mentally ill mother. She has yet to do so. He's been abandoned and abused over and over, even in death.

And if you have made it all the way through this long, long treatise, I thank you for your time and applaud you for your stamina. And whether you read the whole thing, or just scrolled to the bottom, I encourage you to check out Other Side's eloquent (and much shorter) post on this tragedy.

Thursday, September 4, 2008

Sarah Palin: Community Organizer Second To None

In last night's speech, Sarah Palin, teleprompter intact, decided to go after the heart of America. She decided to go after community organizers:

And since our opponents in this presidential election seem to look down on that experience, let me explain to them what the job involves.

I guess a small-town mayor is sort of like a "community organizer," except that you have actual responsibilities.
In that split second, Sarah Palin became the community organizer with such impact that the rest of us only dream of achieving.

She obviously motivated community organizers to start organizing against her. They have started their own blogsite, with this from the founder of Community Organizers of America, John Raskin:

“Community organizers work in neighborhoods that have been hit hardest by the failing economy,” said John Raskin, founder of Community Organizers of America and a community organizer on the West Side of Manhattan. “The last thing we need is for Republican officials to mock us on television when we’re trying to rebuild the neighborhoods they have destroyed. Maybe if everyone had more houses than they can count, we wouldn’t need community organizers. But I work with people who are getting evicted from their only home. If John McCain and the Republicans understood that, maybe they wouldn’t be so quick to make fun of community organizers like me.”
For being just created today, it has already drawn quite a bit of attraction, that surely will only become greater as time moves on.

She even inspired one young organizer to make a personal "thank you" video (H/T to Illy-T):





Not only did Palin manage to tick off the community organizers, she managed to get other groups roiling as well. Groups like the National Association of Social Workers:

The social work profession takes great pride in its community organizing roots and lauds the contributions of its members, and other professionals, who commit their careers to helping residents of different communities organize their resources and take social action to improve life for themselves and their families. Small town reformers and urban community organizers have much in common.
Trust me when I tell you, social workers make some awfully important decisions, on a daily basis, which are much, much harder than those of a mayor who's biggest concern is making sure there is enough snow for the Iditarod.

But Palin did not motivate just social workers or community organizers. Nope. Not just those people. She ticked off a lot of people, all across the country. How else to explain the fact that the Obama campaign raised $10 million dollars in less then 24 hours of her giving her smarmy, smug, condescending speech.

The venerable James Rowen has more here.